The Federal Reserve sparked a trend of higher interest rates for the first time since 2008 on Wednesday, December 16, 2015[i]. Since then, the Federal Discount rate has gone up by many basis points (bps) numerous times. Although this increase seemed insignificant to some, the trend should continue changing debt structures and eventually profitability margins of corporations.
Graph 1
The main change comes from an adjustment in the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) for the average corporation. Since the increase in the cost of capital is interpreted as an externality, this would create a shift in the WACC from WACC-i to WACC-ii, as shown in Graph 1.
Figure 1
Taking a closer look at the WACC, it’s clear that an increase in the cost of capital will derive from the cost of capital before taxes [Kd] found in Figure 1. Going forward, acquiring money for corporations is going to be costlier, and as a result, fewer projects should be approved since more of them will become unprofitable. The result is that companies holding heavy debt burdens or negative cash flows will find it a lot more difficult to finance their losses. It will be interesting to see how industries perform against the S&P 500 in this new world of higher interest rates. If we treat this as a cycle, it began on December 16, 2015, and will end when the next time the Federal Reserve decides to lower interest rates again.
Tax Reform:
The U.S. Tax Cuts and Jobs Act is also a significant externality affecting corporations as it could decrease the cost of borrowing after taxes as shown in Figure 2. This should have a positive impact on earnings per share (EPS). Although the cost of debt (Kd) will go up, the amount paid in corporate taxes will go down. Higher interest rates and lower corporate tax rates have happened simultaneously only a few times in recent history. Given that these developments affect corporate profitability, they should become significant factors affecting equity performance for some time to come as these forces act as significant externalities on the market.
Figure 2
Historical Outlook:
Finding time periods where the Federal Discount Rate increased as corporate tax rates decreased can give us a clue as to what might happen in the future as both of these effects become more significant. Specifically, we can look at companies that outperformed the S&P 500 during periods of higher interest rates and lower corporate tax rates.
Graph 2
Graph 2 shows three periods when the federal discount rate increased as the corporate tax rate decreased: 1964 to 1966, 1979 to 1980, and 1987 to 1990. Although these periods are in different stages of the business cycle, they can serve as proxies to see which industries will outperform the S&P500 under these new conditions. To test these three periods against the S&P 500, a paired samples t-test with a 95% significance level was performed between 49 industries and the S&P 500[ii].
Null Hypothesis:
Alternative Hypothesis:
Table 1
Net Neutrality:
From the results shown in Table 1, the telecommunications industry stands out the most due to the changes in net neutrality laws, which recently have mostly been dismantled [iii]. This should allow telecommunication companies to increase their EPS as they expand their Internet services throughout the country[iv]. Although it is uncertain whether companies such as Verizon and AT&T will be able to increase their market shares, the demand for a more extensive telecommunications infrastructure is very likely as we get closer to 5G cellular technology[v].
Graph 3
Dollar:
The decline in value of the U.S. dollar, as seen in Graph 3, is also a significant trend that affects telecommunication companies with exposure to emerging markets since the USD has been decreasing significantly for over a year and is set to keep declining in 2018[vi]. As emerging and developing currencies continue to get stronger against the USD, it should be easier for people to acquire Internet services, which should increase revenue for telecommunication companies. This is because emerging and developing market economies will be able to spend more on infrastructure and increase private consumption as their purchasing power increases.
Global Growth:
From a macroeconomic perspective, emerging and developing country growth also presents an opportunity for telecommunication companies exposed to emerging market economies. Recently, revisions were made for emerging markets and developing countries to grow to about 4.5%[vii] in 2018. The fact that emerging market indexes have increased at a faster pace relative to the S&P500 is an indication that if this trend continues, emerging markets might outperform the S&P500 again in 2018, calculated by Figure 4 and shown in Graph 4.
Figure 4
Graph 4
Ratio analysis:
A closer look at the telecommunications industry suggests that the companies best suited to take advantage of these changes in the market are companies that should not be heavily impacted by the rising cost of debt. As a result, companies with the best liquidity ratios and cash reserves within the telecommunications industry should have an advantage over others that are not as liquid or overleveraged in the next couple of years. More importantly, companies that can use their assets effectively to generate profits, should be able to continue to grow at previous rates.
Table 2
Although the companies that stand out in Table 2 are AT&T and Verizon Communications, other companies such as American Tower also hold massive amounts of free cash flow to the firm (FCFF), which puts them in a prime position to increase their market capitalization and grow in a higher interest rate environment.
American Tower:
Table 3
American Tower Corp (Ticker: AMT) is an owner, operator, and developer of multi-tenant communications real estate. The company profits from leasing space for communication sites to wireless services and wireless data providers in the U.S. and abroad. Using the basic premise that a firm’s value is the present value of its projected future cash flow, we can get an idea of the company’s fair value using multiple-price methods for valuation as shown in Table 3.
Table 4
Deconstructing the EPS of American Tower in Table 4 reveals that it’s firmly poised for growth. Although financial leverage is increasing, the total asset turnover and total profit margin are also increasing, which is a sign that it’s putting its assets to good use. This is reflected by the fact that its return on assets has increased by 20% from 2016 to 2017.
Graph 5[viii]
This growth could happen via a combination of 5G technology expansion in the U.S. and higher wireless and broadband penetration in emerging and developing countries as shown in Graph 5. Specifically, high growth will be observed in countries such as India and Nigeria, where mobile broadband penetration is still low compared to other rapidly emerging countries.
Graph 6
Externalities:
American Tower is in a rare position to profit from higher interest rates, lower corporate taxes, deregulation of the telecommunications industry in the U.S., a declining dollar, and rising global growth. If deregulation incentivizes telephone companies to upgrade their services to 5G technology, it should be easy for American Tower to increase its profit margins as it increases the number of towers leased to more companies at higher prices. Additional growth in the company’s earnings will hinge on emerging and developing country growth, which should continue in 2018 as shown in Graph 6. Given the current economic externalities and emerging and developing country growth trends, American Tower is a company that might merit a closer look for some investors.
References:
[i] https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/fomcpresconf20151216.htm
[ii] http://mba.tuck.dartmouth.edu/pages/faculty/ken.french/data_library.html
[iii] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/14/technology/net-neutrality-repeal-vote.html
[iv] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/21/technology/fcc-net-neutrality.html
[v] https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/the-downside-of-net-neutrality/
[vi] https://qz.com/1164158/the-us-dollar-just-had-its-worst-year-in-more-than-a-decade-and-2018-will-bring-more-of-the-same/
[vii] http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2018/01/09/global-economy-to-edge-up-to-3-1-percent-in-2018-but-future-potential-growth-a-concern
[viii] http://www.americantower.com/Assets/uploads/files/PDFs/vendor-relations/investor-relations/2016/AMT%20International%20Overview.pdf